Lawmakers urge Legislature to investigate secretary of state over voters wrongly inactivated: ‘He’s shuffling accountability’
By Madeline Nguyen | Originally published by Mississippi Today
Mississippi’s Black lawmakers are pushing for the Legislature to investigate Republican Secretary of State Michael Watson after properly registered voters discovered on Election Day that they were wrongly inactivated based on unverified credit-bureau data deployed by his office.
Democratic lawmakers from the Mississippi Legislative Black Caucus are now joining civil rights groups and voters in demanding answers from Watson after the midterms exposed errors stemming from his office’s $50,000 partnership with Experian to clean the rolls of voters suspected to have moved.
With the investigation, the lawmakers say they are hoping to resolve key questions that have gone publicly unanswered, including how many voters were wrongly inactivated and whether the secretary of state took any action to address the risks.
When the next legislative session kicks off in January, the caucus hopes to push through a package of reforms with Republican support to keep the errors from affecting more voters during Mississippi’s general election next November, when statewide, legislative, district and countywide offices will be on the ballot.
“These voters deserve answers before they cast their ballots, not after,” Sen. Bradford Blackmon, a Democrat from Canton, said at a news conference Thursday at the Capitol. “We cannot afford to enter another election cycle with unanswered questions about the integrity of our voter rolls or uncertainty surrounding the ability of eligible citizens to exercise their constitutional right to vote.”
Democratic Rep. Zakiya Summers of Jackson, a former Hinds County election commissioner who now represents parts of Hinds and Rankin counties, said at the caucus’s news conference that the top priority is to rein in the secretary of state’s broad authority to pick sources for voter roll maintenance as Mississippi’s top election official.
In the midterms, the first federal general election since the secretary of state’s office deployed addresses from Experian’s data to Mississippi’s 82 counties, inactivations and affidavit ballots — a type of vote cast by inactive registrants — surged from their usual levels. As voters turned out in greater numbers, Mississippians who had lived in the same place for years arrived at polling places only to discover their names weren’t in the poll books because the data had placed them at the wrong address.
Eight months before the midterms, Mississippi Today first uncovered that these errors had surfaced in nearly every federal election since the secretary of state began experimenting with the data in 2024. Before then, Mississippi had solely relied on government data, including address information from the U.S. Postal Service, to accomplish the routine job of cleaning the rolls of voters who had died or moved.
After Watson’s office expanded the use of the data statewide, voter inactivations surged before the midterms. By Election Day, some counties saw inactivations more than double, and statewide, over 230,000 registrants — or one in nine voters — were rendered inactive.
Watson wrote in an opinion column Monday that this total is the result of five years of voter roll maintenance from a variety of sources, including Experian’s data, that had flagged “many” voters who had actually died or moved. But voter data from the Associated Press shows the figure was significantly higher than in previous federal election years, before Watson’s office deployed the credit bureau data statewide.
By this Election Day, the total number of inactive voters was nearly 60,000 more than in the 2024 presidential election and 45,000 more than in the 2022 midterms. The difference has fueled voting rights advocates and election commissioners’ concerns that the unverified data is responsible for the surge.
For over a week after voters cast their ballots on Nov. 3, county election commissioners across the state were left to verify and count an uptick in the number of affidavit ballots in a razor-thin U.S. Senate race that ushered Democratic candidate Scott Colom to victory as Mississippi’s first Black senator since Reconstruction.
“No eligible voter should be left confused, turned away without guidance, or denied the opportunity to participate because the process failed them,” Rep. Timaka James-Jones, a Democrat from Belzoni who represents the southern Delta, said at the news conference. “Every Mississippi voter deserves a fair opportunity to be heard.”
Investigation would require Republican support
As a part of the Legislature’s investigation, the caucus demanded the joint Investigate State Offices Committee to publicly question Watson over his office’s decision to authorize the data. Launching an investigation would require the committee’s arms in the Senate and House to agree, although they have been historically dominated by a majority of legislators from Watson’s own Republican Party.
Watson has borne the brunt of criticism from both sides of the aisle for his decision to deploy Experian’s data in a quest for cleaner voter rolls. Four Republican lawmakers last week told Mississippi Today that they were disappointed in Watson’s handling of the data.
A key question the Black Caucus is seeking to answer is what “warnings” Watson’s office received that properly registered voters could be affected by errors in the data.
Watson did not respond to a letter sent days before the midterms from a coalition of national civil rights groups warning that errors tied to the data could disrupt voting, records obtained by Mississippi Today show. To prevent issues from surfacing on Election Day, the groups had called for his office to reactivate voters affected by Experian’s data.
Watson meanwhile has stood by his decision to deploy Experian. He has stated on social media that it was election commissioners’ responsibility to verify any errors in the data.
“Ultimately, no matter what data is sent to the election commissioners, you should understand your job is to verify the information before acting upon it,” Watson stated on Facebook in response to a Lee County election commissioner who raised concerns about the data on Election Day.
But critics have argued that Watson’s office stated the Experian data was “reliable” information.
“I believed the accountability lands with the secretary of state’s office,” Summers said. “It all starts and ends with leadership.”
Legislators look to pass laws to prevent issues from repeating
The caucus plans to file bills preventing the issues from emerging in next year’s statewide elections, in which Watson is running for lieutenant governor. Summers said her top priority is gaining bipartisan support to overhaul House Bill 1310, the law that opened the door for Watson to deploy the credit-bureau data on the voter rolls.
While many states have laws on the books explicitly naming the exact sources that election officials can use for voter roll maintenance, a little-debated clause in HB 1310 broadly allowed Mississippi’s election officials to use “reliable information” indicating that a voter had moved from their registered residence as grounds to mark them inactive.
The bill did not specify any standards that the information had to meet to be considered reliable, but did name examples of what would fit. All were government sources. The bill made no mention of credit bureau data.
A year after the law took effect, Watson wrote he was “excited to report” that HB 1310 allowed his office to deploy Experian’s data on the voter rolls. While his office stated the partnership would bring a “new level of reliable data” to voter roll maintenance, it signed off on disclaimers that the credit bureau could not guarantee the “accuracy or reliability” of its unverified data.
“Voter roll maintenance should not be utilized to punish voters,” Summers said. “We’ve got to make sure we are protecting them, versus weeding people out.”
This article was originally published by Mississippi Today and is republished here under a Creative Commons license.
Source: Original Article





