Mississippi News

Retrial in New Albany stabbing will proceed

By Mina Corpuz | Originally published by Mississippi Today

The U.S. Supreme Court declined Monday to consider double jeopardy issues raised in the case of a north Mississippi man whom a judge acquitted of attempted murder and is set to be retried.

Attorneys for Lane Mitchell asked the nation’s high court last month to hear his case, arguing that a 5-4 Mississippi Appeals Court decision violated their client’s protection from being tried twice for the same charge. 

Mitchell’s case was one of over a 100 petitions for review denied without explanation by the court. Typically, the U.S. Supreme Court accepts very few requests for review. 

Before the high court considered the petition, parents of the victim, Russell Rogers, shared their concerns about how the case was presented to the justices, including how it contained what they called misstatements. 

In 2019, Mitchell, then 18, stabbed Rogers of Collierville, Tennessee, at the Tallahatchie Gourmet restaurant in New Albany, believing the man posed a threat to his father, who was working as a bartender, and to a female waitress. 

After a 2023 trial, Union County Circuit Judge Kent Smith entered an order of acquittal based on the victim’s absence at court, which he said violated Mitchell’s right to confront the accuser of the crime. The defense and prosecutors didn’t present closing arguments, and the  jury hadn’t begun deliberations.

Two years later, the state Court of Appeals said the judge ruled incorrectly and reversed the ruling and sent it back to be tried again. Retrial is scheduled for March 2027.

When reached Monday after the U.S. Supreme Court’s decision, Maridonna Rogers wondered how a new trial will be any different if it is tried with the same judge in the same county.


This article was originally published by Mississippi Today and is republished here under a Creative Commons license.

Source: Original Article

Advertisement

STAY CONNECTED

DeSoto County, wherever you are.

Follow DeSoto County News on Facebook, watch Mississippi News Group on YouTube, and get local news in your inbox.